Score: 5.00 Votes: 8
rate this

Opinion boys...can it work again? Thanks everyone for the advice!

Starter: cyber167 Posted: 18 years ago Views: 7.9K
  • Goto:
#3139501
Lvl 7
THANK YOU ALL FOR THE RESPONSE, I TRULY APPRECIATE IT GUYS!

Hi there, long time lurker here. I 've been reading in the Lounge for a while and know that there are many old and wise guys in here, so I guess I need your view or opinion on my situation. My girlfriend of the time (for 6 years) went to visit family in the US and while she was there cheated on me with a guy over about 7-10 days I think. She was there for a month, and this happened at the end of her trip.

I found out (she didn't tell me) and she also said she wanted us to split as we weren\'t working anymore. Just so you know, I'm a good guy, never mistreated her or anything. Up to this point she was great as a partner, she put on a bit of weight which didn't matter to me at all. She was loyal, caring, loving and all that. I wasn't far off proposing to her.

We didn\'t speak for a while, as there was some fallout, but I kept pushing for us to be friends as I didn't want to lose someone so close, even as a friend. We started talking aain when she realised that she'd lose a lot if she lost me as a friend. She was in touch with this guy regularly, then that contact died off as I don't think he did long distance communucating well. In the last 3 weeks before she went home, we spent every moment together outside of work, trying to get some sort of friendship going again. We did, and she was house sitting for a friend and had me over to stay every night, we hooked up here and there which was fun. In the last week before she left, she stayed with me (back at the place she moved out of 5 days after I found out) and we had 24/7 time together.

She said (THIS IS WHAT I WANT YOU OPINION ON!) that she wants to be with me but it wouldn\'t work right now. I couldn\'t be with her right now due to the cheating, but people make mistakes. She also said that she could see us growing old together etc, but that we both need to go away, make the changes we both want to make, and then re-introduce ourselves when the time was right. She said a lot of Ilove yous and I\'ll miss yous at the airport, and in the days before leaving, and she is a genuine girl so I have no reason to doubt that she meant it. But I knew that when she got home, there would be a guy waiting for her and she would be straight into this new relationship, and as far as I can tell she has.

He is 3 years younger, she is 28. He met his previous girl through cheating by the way. So it\'s hard, as some of the things she said were very loving and sweet and assured me that (the way she felt right now) she did want me as her future, but that it wouldn\'t work right now. She said she is scared that I\'ll meet someone in the meantime and that her chance would be lost with me. She says she doesn\'t see this new guy as a long term thing, but how would she know. She is all that I know guys, so for good or bad, I do love her and want to be with her, but I\'m not going to sit around doing nothing. I think I have built her up in my mind over the years as the\"one\" when there must be other great girls out there (that don\'t cheat too). I haven\'t been single in 10 years (I\'m 28) and it\'s a bit scary to be honest.

So here is my question, do you think there\'s a chance that two people could go away for a time and get back together like that? Should I just bury the whole experience with her and move on to someone new? Should I tell her to fuck off? She is scared she is making a huge mistake by going back home and breaking up. She is also worried that I have a new great job and managing my money better, I might be making the changes she needed me to make, and someone else will benefit. I told her that the next person that came along would get the benefit of all the lessons I have learnt from this, and she was sad when she heard that. I told her my best was yet to come, which I truly believe, which also made her sad. She pretty much wants to be with this new guy and have fun, while keeping me on standby for when she wants to get serious about a life partner. She most likely loves the attention of 2 guys as well. I have been in touch with her since she got home to the States, and she was sad on the first chat, missing me, but she\'s been fine since, as she\'s with the new guy now. I\'ve just been friendly and normal on the phone, with no sappy \"i miss you\' except for the first chat. I think she will let her guard down on a drunken late night call and show how she is feeling about all of this.

She wants us to be close as friends, and said she wants to see the changes I said I would make, I think she wants to keep tabs on who I might be with, and if I\'m still feeling anything for mer. She knows how strongly I feel for her, and that I hope it works in the future, trust would be a big factor, and one she said she wanted to gain back as friends. Anyway, thank you so much for reading this, is a huge part of my life that has changed, and any opinion is welcome , really.
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139502
Lvl 23
Her loss, move on.
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139503
Lvl 7
That's what my friends are all saying. I just find it hard as I was (an am) convinced she's my "one". 6 years together tols me that, and she never got old and I never looked elsewhere. I know there are many cool chicks out there, I'm just out of practice! I know I'm a good guy and was good to her, no bullshit. Thanks for reading it.
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139504
Lvl 11
http://www.whatboyswant.com/forum_read/3445919/1/

"I Keep Looking"

Back when I was young
Couldn't wait to grow up
Get away and get out on my own
And looking back now
Ain't it funny how
I've been trying to get back home, yeah

When my low self esteem
Needs a man loving me
And I find me a perfect catch
Then I see my friends
Having wild weekends
Then I don't wanna get quite so attached
Just as soon as I get what I want
I get unsatisfied
Good is good but could be better

I keep looking, I keep looking for
I keep looking for something more
I always wonder what's on the other side
Of the number two door
I keep looking
Looking for something more


Well, the straight haired girls
They all want curls
And the brunettes wanna be blonde
It's your typical thing
You got ying you want yang
It just goes on and on
They say, hey, it's only human
To never be satisfied
Well I guess that I'm as human as the next one

Oh, I keep looking
I keep looking for
I keep looking for something more
I always wonder what's on the other side
Of the number two door
Yeah, I keep looking
Looking for something more

Just as soon as I get what I want
I get unsatisfied
Hey, good is good but could be better

I keep looking
I keep looking for
I keep looking for something more
I always wonder what's on the other side
Of the number two door
I keep looking
Looking for something more
Oh, looking for something more

===============================================

dude, she don't deserve you. it hurts and it may not make sense since you invested heavily into the relationship but you have to move on without her.

once a cheater, always a cheater!
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139505
Lvl 59
tl;dr

Is there a Cliff's Notes version of this thread I can read?
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139506
Lvl 20
Dude, I know it's hard but you have got to give her up. She clearly shows that she's not as in to your relationship as you are. Find yourself a girl that don't have to have another guy too and that can "satisfy" herself with only you!
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139507
Lvl 23
Quote:
Originally posted by EricLindros

tl;dr

Is there a Cliff's Notes version of this thread I can read?


Girlfriend of 6 years goes to the U.S. and cheats on him,
he finds out,
they break up,
they fuck a couple more times before she moves back to the U.S. where the other guy is waiting,
before she leaves, she says she loves him and wants to be with him in the future, not now

Pretty much, she wants him to be there just in case shit doesn't work out with this guy or the (many) others that will follow - he's her back up plan.

He wants to know if it will work out.
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139508
Lvl 6
She wants it all and expects you to hang around until she ready?!!! Tell her that doesnt work on "PLANET REALITY"
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139509
Lvl 9
Instant thought is forget her and move on but then you remember the love you feel. I had a 7 month split with my misses and we both had other things happen in that time and i never saw a way back. Then we met up over christmas and realised we'd still got something. It hasn't been easy and people probably from both sides called us foolish but we're now happier than ever and been back together for over 2 years. Man while she is in doubt use the time to get your head sorted enjoy spending time with family friends let loose and do the things you've held back from. You'll either realise she is worth the wait or you may stumble across somebody that deserves you. GOOD LUCK!
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139510
Lvl 37
If she don't want you, then she is not worth waiting for!
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139511
Lvl 7
move on if its meant to be it will happen. dont shut yourself off from other chances of a new best friend or possible love.SHE HASNT.
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139512
Lvl 7
Tell the GIRL to either stay and make it work or get fucked and leave you to get on with your life

-------------------------------------------------
DO NOT USE DEROGATORY TERMS TO DESCRIBE WOMEN, EVEN IF THEY DESERVE IT
* This post has been modified by [Deleted] : 18 years ago
#3139513
Lvl 24
Quote:
Originally posted by HighGuy

[reply=EricLindros]
tl;dr

Is there a Cliff's Notes version of this thread I can read?


Girlfriend of 6 years goes to the U.S. and cheats on him,
he finds out,
they break up,
they fuck a couple more times before she moves back to the U.S. where the other guy is waiting,
before she leaves, she says she loves him and wants to be with him in the future, not now

Pretty much, she wants him to be there just in case shit doesn't work out with this guy or the (many) others that will follow - he's her back up plan.

He wants to know if it will work out.
[/reply]

Pretty much yeah.

Dude, go... find out if she has a sister or something.
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139514
Lvl 24
As conflicted as you are right now, you'll only live to regret it even more and suffer more pain if you get back together. She betrayed your trust and broke it off with you.....she says she needs you and wants to be with you but that would allow her to use you....You have to be strong enough to protect yourself and MOVE ON! It's a big world and you will get over it....she doesn't deserve you...she matched your love and intention to propose with an affair ....bad equation....Let some other guy be the butt of her infidelity....you can and should do better...and your heart will heal, brother....trust us all on that...you gotta walk away, or better yet....run away...just get on with your life without her...you will NEVER be able to trust her 100%....without that, any relationship is doomed to ultimately fail...You are better off distancing yourself NOW.
Good luck with your life.....make it as good as it can be, dude...you only get one.
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139515
Lvl 9
She sounds like she aint changin, High Guy said it right, yer her backup if slutin' around don't work out, move on, another girl will appreciate you more
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139516
Lvl 8
Quote:
Originally posted by burger167

Hi there, long time lurker here. I 've been reading in the Lounge for a while and know that there are many old and wise guys in here, so I guess I need your view or opinion on my situation. My girlfriend of the time (for 6 years) went to visit family in the US and while she was there cheated on me with a guy over about 7-10 days I think. She was there for a month, and this happened at the end of her trip.

I found out (she didn't tell me) and she also said she wanted us to split as we weren\'t working anymore. Just so you know, I'm a good guy, never mistreated her or anything. Up to this point she was great as a partner, she put on a bit of weight which didn't matter to me at all. She was loyal, caring, loving and all that. I wasn't far off proposing to her.

We didn\'t speak for a while, as there was some fallout, but I kept pushing for us to be friends as I didn't want to lose someone so close, even as a friend. We started talking aain when she realised that she'd lose a lot if she lost me as a friend. She was in touch with this guy regularly, then that contact died off as I don't think he did long distance communucating well. In the last 3 weeks before she went home, we spent every moment together outside of work, trying to get some sort of friendship going again. We did, and she was house sitting for a friend and had me over to stay every night, we hooked up here and there which was fun. In the last week before she left, she stayed with me (back at the place she moved out of 5 days after I found out) and we had 24/7 time together.

She said (THIS IS WHAT I WANT YOU OPINION ON!) that she wants to be with me but it wouldn\'t work right now. I couldn\'t be with her right now due to the cheating, but people make mistakes. She also said that she could see us growing old together etc, but that we both need to go away, make the changes we both want to make, and then re-introduce ourselves when the time was right. She said a lot of Ilove yous and I\'ll miss yous at the airport, and in the days before leaving, and she is a genuine girl so I have no reason to doubt that she meant it. But I knew that when she got home, there would be a guy waiting for her and she would be straight into this new relationship, and as far as I can tell she has.

He is 3 years younger, she is 28. He met his previous girl through cheating by the way. So it\'s hard, as some of the things she said were very loving and sweet and assured me that (the way she felt right now) she did want me as her future, but that it wouldn\'t work right now. She said she is scared that I\'ll meet someone in the meantime and that her chance would be lost with me. She says she doesn\'t see this new guy as a long term thing, but how would she know. She is all that I know guys, so for good or bad, I do love her and want to be with her, but I\'m not going to sit around doing nothing. I think I have built her up in my mind over the years as the\"one\" when there must be other great girls out there (that don\'t cheat too). I haven\'t been single in 10 years (I\'m 28) and it\'s a bit scary to be honest.

So here is my question, do you think there\'s a chance that two people could go away for a time and get back together like that? Should I just bury the whole experience with her and move on to someone new? Should I tell her to fuck off? She is scared she is making a huge mistake by going back home and breaking up. She is also worried that I have a new great job and managing my money better, I might be making the changes she needed me to make, and someone else will benefit. I told her that the next person that came along would get the benefit of all the lessons I have learnt from this, and she was sad when she heard that. I told her my best was yet to come, which I truly believe, which also made her sad. She pretty much wants to be with this new guy and have fun, while keeping me on standby for when she wants to get serious about a life partner. She most likely loves the attention of 2 guys as well. I have been in touch with her since she got home to the States, and she was sad on the first chat, missing me, but she\'s been fine since, as she\'s with the new guy now. I\'ve just been friendly and normal on the phone, with no sappy \"i miss you\' except for the first chat. I think she will let her guard down on a drunken late night call and show how she is feeling about all of this.

She wants us to be close as friends, and said she wants to see the changes I said I would make, I think she wants to keep tabs on who I might be with, and if I\'m still feeling anything for mer. She knows how strongly I feel for her, and that I hope it works in the future, trust would be a big factor, and one she said she wanted to gain back as friends. Anyway, thank you so much for reading this, is a huge part of my life that has changed, and any opinion is welcome , really.
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139517
Lvl 8
My Friend, I have been n that situation but me being the girl. I had this perfect girlfriend but was very young and still wanted to party. We finished by my choice and told her if we was ment to be together then we would be together again. Since then she is got with a good guy I must admit (which makes it harder) but what I am saying is that if things are ment to be then there are ment to be. Dont wait for her dont think about what if but you NEED to move and create a new life for yourself. Who knows your ONE as you say could be round the corner waiting. If you have your head down thinking of her then you could miss this new girl. She has made the decision to 'have fun' and wants you for a husband, but ask yourself this. When you are a husband to her and she gets bored will she look for fun again. Not good foundations is it.
if you want my advice I say go out there with your head up and have fun yourself. You say you have not been single for a while but mate its not scary, just have fun. If you get bored and you still want her then fine but dont waist your time waiting. GO OUT THERE.

If you want to chat then let me know.

All the best.

Craig
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139518
Lvl 10
move on
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139519
Lvl 12
simple answer - she cannot have her cake and eat it
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
#3139520
Lvl 7
walk on, its tough but do it... once a cheat always a cheat... the same thing happened to me after 10 years... I wasted a year trying to save it before admitting that if she cheated it points to something seriously wrong... found someone else two years later, glad it all happened and couldnt be happier now..
* This post has been modified : 18 years ago
  • Goto: