Quote:
Originally posted by SP
Why does music all music have to meaning, soul, and taste?
Because it is indicators of integrity on the musicians part and lasting power, it shouldn't be about making as money as possible for as little work and inspiration as possible. There is nothing wrong with a catchy beat, but when it lacks any intelligence it is a waste of time and further encourages the cycle of garbage in and garbage out, every time just lowering the bar further.
Quote:
Originally posted by SP
Why can't it just be something that puts a smile on your face today, and is forgotten about tomorrow?
Watering down something is still watering down and lowering the bar for what is considered music. The continued lowering of artistic merit is slowing down culture and in fact retarding our progress in culture. The more this goes on the more of a mono-culture we become and it stifles outside and alternative forms of culture. Instead of fostering imagination, talent, and exertion we are just saying "yeah this is acceptable and this what we should have." Instead of coming up with something new they just repeat the patterns of past success. People entering the field will see that it is the only lucrative way to exist and it will become the norm.
We already have an example of how it happened so fast in the gaming industry. Where video games started off as a challenge to explore, learn tactics, become better at game mechanics. Now it has boiled down to the massive junkers of today where you are lead by the hand from set point to set point, no freedom, no exploration, no mechanic mastery and now you have $60 games that have a solo campaign of a few hours.
There is nothing wrong with a dumb song coming out every once and while but when it becomes the norm and it is repeated on en masse we are killing culture.
Quote:
Originally posted by SP
Do you think when cavemen first pounded drums that they thought, "this song is about the trials and tribulations of hunting mastodons, and is in memory of Grog, may he rest in peace"
Most likely they did, just as those paintings on the walls were there to describe and convey a message to future generations. They didn't just do it because it looked pretty and it made them happy. It all began as a part of a survival mechanism to share information. Music can be used to alter mood and behavior of people but also to convey a message. A lot of scholars believe it all started with rituals and ceremonies; and those aren't going to be frivolous feel good bullshits.
Quote:
Originally posted by SP
No...they fucking liked he sound of it, and gave them something to do other than draw figures on cave walls.
Ehhhh, wrong. Prehistoric races weren't bored and trying to kill time. There was always work and survival on the line very unlike today. They couldn't go out to a grocery store and pick up a frozen TV dinner. You're reasoning that they had lifestyles like ours, but they didn't. They spent their time hunting, defending against predators, gathering resources and food, and surviving the day. They just didn't sit there, slack jawed staring at the wall. Grog wasn't singing about how like's big butts and how Grog cannot lie.
If you were dumped into the wilderness with predators around, with a knife and nothing else are you going to sit there and sing? No, you are going to try and survive the night. Although knowing you, you probably would hum about big booties.