Quote:
Originally posted by rocknthefreewor
[reply=nerdboy]
ok, to sum up the thread in 3 short sentences.
We'll see about that.
Quote:
Originally posted by nerdboy
1. America is far from civilized
I would argue that America is at least as civilized as any other country on the planet. More so than many of them. This is because America's civilization is based on the best parts of everyone elses. Yes we have problems, but it is still a lot better than most.
Quote:
Originally posted by nerdboy
2. your rights end where the other guy's begin
This is partly true. Where the other guys rights begin is up for debate though. Shouldn't a bar owner have the right to allow smoking if he wants? It infringes on noones rights as the workers and patrons have the choice not to go there and once they make the choice to go there they have made the choice to forgo the right to a non-smoking environment. Same goes for dogs or cats in bars. Logan's roadhouse has a long standing tradition of having people eat peanuts at their tables and throw the shells on the floor like an old Texas roadhouse used to do. Should we stop that because some people are alergic to peanuts? When you leave an open end to where rights begin and end you are asking for a dull society and a nanny state.
We do agree on one thign though.
Quote:
Originally posted by nerdboy
3. Jeff is writing essays AGAIN
[/reply]
I missed the part were it say that citizens have the right to smoke in the constitution. Maybe its in the bill of rights?
Bars are public areas. Second hand smoke has been proven to be harmful (not saying I agree). Small children, people with asthma, small children with asthma might be particularly vulnerable to second hand smoke. They have a right to be in public areas and the right to live. Those rights outweigh the bar owners rights. (I’m not saying I’m for/against smokers).
Nerboy is right
* This post has been modified
: 19 years ago