Quote:
Originally posted by Jeff613
Why would we expect any less from a visiting superior alien race?
Because it's generally thought that magnanimity is inherently tied to vastly superior intelligence.
Of course, that's not necessarily true, but it's the common assumption...
Quote:
Originally posted by blabbermouth
But what if we were visited by aliens who were less advanced than us? They may not necessarily be more advanced than we are. Why do we always assume they would be? What if they were from a world that had purposely limited the scope of it's technology? What if our ability to feel emotions was something which gave us a huge edge over them in terms of overall superiority? We''ve invented some pretty amazing things on accident, what if they're actually pretty dumb but managed to stumble upon interstellar space travel? The guy who first discovered and described DNA credits an offhand LSD trip with his discovery after all.
Are you kidding me?
Yeah, it's likely that foreign beings with the ability to travel millions upon millions of miles through space, search out and find a tiny planet with some semi-intelligent life on it, make contact with them, and accidentally get crushed by us? I mean, really? Do you have any idea of the amount of technical knowledge required for space travel? The logistics of it ridiculous.
And you honestly think our emotions give us an edge over some vastly superior alien race? If anything, our emotions disable us from making the best choices and generally continually cloud our judgment. They're a hindrance to the scientific mind and would in no way allow us to assert dominance over this stupid alien invasion.
And finally, did you write the movie "Signs?" Because, it seems to me that only someone stupid enough to think that aliens, capable of interstellar travel (putting the word "space" in there is redundant), who happen to die when coming in contact with water, land on a ball that is 70% covered in the stuff inhabited by people who are 70-90% water. That'd be like us landing on some planet with oceans of and people made of cyanide, saying, "Meh, seems ok"